
So
Banned Books Week begins tomorrow. It celebrates the importance of the First Amendment and the freedom (and right) to choose what one wishes to read. It's quite surprising which books have been challenged or banned and on what grounds. There are the usual suspects, of course, such as Twain's
Huckleberry Finn (inappropriate racial slurs),
The Catcher in the Rye (because it's "a filthy, filthy book"), and
The Satanic Verses (blasphemy!), the
Harry Potter novels (Satanism and anti-family sentiments - really?) and Philip Pullman's
Dark Materials trilogy (anti-religious, political stance). But also the
Lord of the Rings (burned in New Mexico as satanic),
Song of Solomon (apparently it's "filth", "trash" and "repulsive"),
As I Lay Dying (questions the existence of God - also contains a passage about masturbation), and
The Grapes of Wrath (the names of God and Jesus are used "in a vain and profane manner"). Mostly it appears to be issues of sex (and homosexuality), inappropriate language, and the horrors and contagion of irreligious or "
humanist" thinking (with a minority upset by the use of racial slurs).
To show my solidarity with these and other writers, I'm reading a book that I own and that has suffered from repeated attempts to silence it's voice. Not sure which, though. It's between
Nineteen Eighty-Four ("pro-communist"), The Satanic Verses ("blasphemous to the prophet Mohammed" and Islam and the Koran, too, of course),
Brave New World ("orgies, self-flogging, suicide" with characters who show "contempt for religion, marriage and the family",
and it makes promiscuous sex "look like fun"), and
The Great Gatsby ("language and sexual references"). I considered The Catcher in the Rye but I've read it twice and I really prefer Salinger's stories. I'll probably pick one of the shorter works because I'm currently reading Crowley's
Ægypt tetralogy, plus I just began
Don Quixote (suffered water damage at some point), not to mention books borrowed from the library for research. In fact, I think it'll have to be Brave New World. Any book that can make promiscuity fun deserves a repeated reading. And I encourage everyone to read one of the challenged books from the
American Library Association's list (even the
Gossip Girl books have the right to be read and to an audience, I suppose).